|
|
||||||||
College of Veterinary Medicine, University of Missouri, Columbia 65211
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: Beef cattle Carcass Composition Respiratory Diseases Anorexia Cytokines
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
In their review of feedlot cattle growth, Owens et al. (1995)
summarized that rate and composition of tissue accretion may be controlled by chronological age, physiological age, energy intake, hormonal status, relative turnover of tissues, cell number, and cell activity. Disease could conceivably affect all these control processes except chronological age. Mechanisms linking disease and carcass traits are not established at this time. Further research is required to understand how cattle disease affects carcass traits.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Carcasses from steers without respiratory tract lesions had a greater degree of marbling than carcasses from steers with lesions (P < 0.01; Gardner et al., 1999
). Additionally, carcasses from steers with lung lesions and active bronchial lymph nodes tended to have lower marbling scores than carcasses from steers with lung lesions but without active bronchial lymph nodes (P < 0.06; Gardner et al., 1999
). As a result, steers that had lungs with active bronchial lymph nodes tended to produce a higher percentage of USDA Standard grade carcasses at the expense of USDA Choice and Select carcasses (P < 0.07; Gardner et al., 1999
). Longissimus shear force values for steaks aged 7 d were lower (P = 0.05) from steers without lung lesions than those for steaks from steers with lung lesions; however, shear force values were similar for steaks aged 14 or 21 d (Gardner et al., 1999
).
Relationship Between Clinical Signs of BRD and Carcass Traits
Gardner et al. (1999)
reported that 37% of cattle that had clinical signs consistent with BRD and that were treated with appropriate antimicrobial therapy during the feedlot phase of production had lung lesions at slaughter. In comparison, 29% of cattle not identified with clinical signs of BRD had lung lesions. This apparent lack of strong association between clinical signs of BRD and lung lesions has been reported by others (Wittum et al., 1996
; Buhman et al., 2000
). The lack of lung lesions in cattle diagnosed by clinical signs and treated for BRD could be due to several factors, including upper respiratory tract disease or transient lower respiratory tract disease that does not result in lung pathology, full recovery from lower respiratory tract disease, with complete resolution of lung lesions, or incorrect clinical assessment for the presence of BRD. In contrast, the presence of lesions at slaughter in the lungs of cattle not diagnosed with BRD could be due to respiratory tract disease that was not accompanied by clinical signs of BRD, chronic lung damage that occurred due to a BRD event before the time period of the investigation, or incorrect clinical assessment for the absence of BRD. Not all feedlot calves infected with known respiratory tract pathogens, as evidenced by seroconversion during finishing, are identified as having clinical signs of BRD (Martin and Bohac, 1986
). It is not known if these subclinical infections could result in visible lung damage at slaughter or if they influence carcass traits.
When Gardner et al. (1999)
used the presence of clinical signs consistent with BRD (i.e., depression, lack of fill, slow movement, and, in some cases, nasal and ocular discharge and a soft cough) rather than lung lesions to indicate BRD incidence, they found that steers with clinical signs of BRD had lower hot carcass weight, less external and internal fat, and more desirable yield grades than steers without clinical signs of BRD. In contrast with steers with lung lesions (regardless of presence of clinical signs), steers with clinical signs of BRD (regardless of presence of lung lesions) tended to have larger (P = 0.12) LM area than untreated animals (Gardner et al., 1999
). Evidence that marbling score was lower in carcasses from steers with clinical signs of BRD compared with carcasses from steers without clinical signs of BRD was present (P = 0.16), but was not as strong as evidence for the difference between carcasses from steers differentiated by the presence or absence of lung lesions (P < 0.01; Gardner et al., 1999
). When using clinical signs of BRD as the criterion for BRD incidence, Gardner et al. (1999)
found that steers treated for BRD at the feedyard tended to have a higher percentage of carcasses that graded USDA Standard and a lower percentage that graded USDA Choice or USDA Select than steers that were not treated, but the mean quality grade did not differ (P = 0.93). There was no difference in dressing percent between steers with or without clinical signs of BRD (Gardner et al., 1999
).
Effect of Prolonged or Repeated Treatments for BRD on Carcass Traits
Some investigators have indicated that cattle treated more than one time for BRD had more pronounced negative growth and carcass effects than cattle treated only once (Gardner et al., 1999
; Stovall et al., 2000
; Roeber et al., 2001
). Gardner et al. (1999)
reported that steers treated for BRD only once gained faster (P < 0.05), had more external and internal fat (P < 0.01), had a higher dressing percent (P < 0.06), a heavier carcass (P < 0.07), and a higher numerical yield grade (P = 0.07) than steers treated more than one time for BRD. There was no difference in LM area or Warner-Bratzler shear force for steaks between steers treated once or more than once for BRD (Gardner et al., 1999
). Cattle treated more than once tended to have lower marbling scores than those treated only once (P = 0.15).
In a study of 273 steer calves, Roeber et al. (2001)
found no difference in carcass traits between cattle that had never been treated for BRD and those that had received one treatment. In contrast, they found that steers receiving two or more treatments for BRD had lower hot carcass weight, marbling score, dressing percent, and yield grade (P < 0.05) compared with cattle not diagnosed with BRD (Roeber et al., 2001
). Warner-Brazler shear force values and palatability of longissimus steaks were not associated with whether the steer had been treated for BRD, or the number of BRD treatments (Roeber et al., 2001
). Another study found that feedlot heifers treated more than one time for BRD had lower marbling scores than heifers never treated (P < 0.02), which resulted in a 37.9% decrease in the percentage of carcasses grading USDA Choice or greater (Stovall et al., 2000
).
Signals Regulating Muscle Growth and Fat Deposition
The regulation of muscle growth and fat deposition in beef cattle has not been fully elucidated. Hormones such as insulin, IGF-I, GH, thyroid hormone, and leptin contribute to the partitioning of nutrients for tissue growth (Anderson et al., 1988
; Rosemberg et al., 1989
; Istasse et al., 1990
; Trout and Schanbacher, 1990
; Enright et al., 1993
; Henricks et al., 1994
; Rohner-Jeanrenaud, 1999
; Vesstergaard et al., 2003). There is also evidence that disease mediators such as IL-1
, IL-1ß, and tumor necrosis factor-
(TNF
; cytokines) can also play a role in nutrient partitioning (Kelley et al., 1993
; Williams et al., 1997
; Raina and Jeejeebhoy, 1998
; Pond, 2002
; Pond and Mattacks, 2002
; Broussard et al., 2003
).
In healthy growing bulls, serum concentrations of GH and IGF-I are negatively correlated with carcass fat percent, fat accretion rate, and fat thickness; moreover IGF-I concentrations were positively correlated with percentage of carcass protein (Anderson et al., 1988
). Carcass weight, dressing percent, and the proportion of lean meat in the carcass of fattening bulls are positively correlated with the total peak area or peak amplitude of growth hormone secretion (Istasse et al., 1990
). In sheep, exogenous GH decreases fat content and increases the protein and water content of carcasses (Bass et al., 1991
). Investigation of the mode of action of growth promoting implants has indicated that GH, IGF-I, and IGFBP play roles in mediating the growth response to both endogenous and exogenous estrogens and androgens (Gopinath and Kitts, 1984
; Grigsby and Trenkle, 1986
; Johnson et al., 1996
; Trenkle, 1997
).
In some studies, insulin concentration is positively correlated with fat content in the carcass and negatively correlated with the proportion of muscle (Istasse et al., 1990
). In other studies, insulin did not seem to play a definable role in body composition (Anderson et al., 1988
) or seemed to have a negative relationship with marbling (Mir et al., 2002
).
Thyroid hormones are important mediators of metabolism throughout the body. The plasma concentrations of triiodothyronine (T3) and tetraiodothyronine (T4) and their ratios with IGF-I were negatively correlated with carcass muscle mass (Istasse et al., 1990
). Similarly, steers with higher plasma T4 had increased fat deposition but tended to have lower protein deposition than steers with lower T4 levels (Rumsey et al., 1987
). In contrast, Enright et al. (1993)
found that treatment of heifers with thyrotropin-releasing hormone (TRH) did not affect carcass weight, dressing percent, backfat thickness, or internal organ weight; however, a combination of GH-releasing factor and TRH decreased fat score and increased LM area relative to no hormonal treatment or treatment with either GH-releasing factor or TRH alone. Cortisol directly inhibits pituitary thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) and may suppress 5' deiodinase, which converts the less active T4 to T3 (Sharpe, 1986
).
Glucocorticoids cause protein catabolism and support increased lipid storage (Rohner-Jeanrenaud, 1999
). Investigations testing the effect of exogenous glucocorticoids, such as dexamethasone, on carcass characteristics have shown that a single injection of dexamethasone to steers at least 33 d preslaughter resulted in increased marbling score in one study (Brethour, 1972
). Similarly, injecting bulls with dexamethasone either once or twice within 92 d of slaughter resulted in higher mean values for marbling and quality grade than untreated controls (Dicke et al., 1974
). In contrast, chronic exposure of steers to dexamethasone via a s.c. implant did not enhance i.m. fat deposition (Corah et al., 1995
). Steers treated with a dexamethasone implant did, however, have greater external fat thickness, higher dressing percent, and a larger LM area compared with untreated controls (Corah et al., 1995
). In trials using rats, infusion with corticosterone caused muscle catabolism (Raina and Jeejeebhoy, 1998
).
The cytokine TNF
is released by activated macrophages in response to inflammation or infection in swine (Webel et al., 1997
). Very low physiological concentrations of TNF
act on porcine muscle cells to interfere with protein synthesis and muscle cell development by inducing a state of IGF-I receptor resistance (Broussard et al., 2003
). Even though IGF-I is a strong inducer of protein syntheses in myoblasts, the presence of proinflammatory cytokines somehow interferes with the IGF-I promotion of muscle growth (Broussard et al., 2003
). The mechanism of this interference may be that hormones and cytokines appear to share some intracellular substrates, and this indicates that they might be involved in the regulation of each other (Hirosumi et al., 2002
; Broussard et al., 2003
). Receptors for some cytokines (IL-2, IL-4, IL-9, and interferon-
) use intra-cellular docking molecules that were first identified in rodents for the insulin receptor (White and Yenush, 1998
). Therefore, the stimulation of TNF
impairs activation of signaling elements of the insulin receptor (Hirosumi et al., 2002
).
Stimulation of the pigs immune system results in increased plasma concentrations of cytokines and cortisol (Webel et al., 1997
). These metabolically active molecules seem to be involved in the reduction of feed intake, increased muscle protein degradation, and decreased growth in diseased or immunologically challenged pigs (Webel et al., 1997
).
Whether disease affects carcass traits in beef cattle by influencing the signals regulating muscle growth and fat deposition has not been directly investigated. Potential links between infectious disease, cytokines and cortisol, and body composition can be made, but much more investigation is required to test these links.
Regulatory Control of Fat Metabolism
The regulatory mechanism and maturing pattern for i.m. fat deposition may be different than for other fat depots in sheep (Belk et al., 1993
). Brethour (2000)
found that the correlation between backfat thickness and marbling score of feedlot cattle was low (r2 = 0.07 to 0.16). This weak relationship and differences in rate of fat accretion over time indicate that the s.c. fat depot and the i.m. fat depot accumulate lipid independently and are possibly controlled by different mechanisms. Smith and Crouse (1984)
found that in vitro, s.c. bovine adipose tissue preferred acetate for fat synthesis, whereas muscle preferred glucose for the synthesis of i.m. fat. They hypothesized that decreased glucose availability may decrease marbling potential (Smith and Crouse, 1984
).
Fat can be mobilized as an energy source in mammals in response to a metabolic need, such as response to inflammation, but different fat depots respond differently (Pond, 2002
; Pond and Mattacks, 2002
). Adipocytes of lymph node-containing fat depots undergo lipolysis in response to inflammation of the enclosed lymph node. This response is probably mediated by cytokines (Pond, 2002
). Intermuscular (seam) and i.m. fat may also respond to similar paracrine signals of inflammation, but external fat that is not associated with lymph nodes does not appear to undergo lipolysis under the same conditions (Pond, 2002
).
Potential Effects of Anorexia on Carcass Characteristics
Direct Effects.
Animals infected with pathogenic microorganisms show various behavioral symptoms of sickness including lethargy, anorexia, adipsia, and decreased social interactions (Kelley et al., 1993
; Dantzer, 2001
). Cytokines and endotoxin induce sickness behavior in the form of reduced food intake and decreased social interactions (Dantzer, 2001
). In trials using rats, infusion with TNF
caused weight loss due to anorexia (Raina and Jeejeebhoy, 1998
). Interleukin-1
, IL-1ß, and TNF-
are the most potent proinflammatory cytokines to induce behavioral alterations, and it seems that different components of sickness behavior are mediated by different cytokines (Dantzer et al., 1998
). Eating and drinking behavior is affected by respiratory tract disease in feedlot cattle (Sowell et al., 1999
; Buhman et al., 2000
). Buhman et al. (2000)
found that calves that had lung lesions at slaughter had a lower frequency of eating 11 to 27 d after arrival but had greater frequency of eating 28 to 57 d after arrival than calves without lung lesions. Similarly, Sowell et al. (1999)
found that healthy steers had more daily feeding events than morbid steers over a 32-d receiving trial. Although Buhman et al. (2000)
found that sick calves had greater frequency and duration of drinking 4 to 5 d after arrival than calves that were not sick, Sowell et al. (1999)
did not detect a difference in daily time spent at the water trough between healthy and sick calves.
Bulls that were restricted to an intake of 1.5% of BW for 84 d and then realimented with an intake of 3.2% of BW until slaughter at 422 kg had less fat but the same amount of lean tissue as bulls consistently fed 3.2% of BW (Henricks et al., 1994
). The bulls that had been restricted early in the feeding period required 35 d more on feed than nonrestricted cattle to reach the same slaughter weight. During the feed restriction period, serum GH concentration was higher in restricted bulls than in unrestricted bulls on feed the same number of days. Conversely, restricted bulls had lower serum IGF-I concentration than unrestricted bulls. Once intake restriction ended, serum GH and IGF-I were similar among treatment groups. Henricks et al. (1994)
pointed out that multiple signals seem to interact to regulate nutrient partitioning and tissue growth, and that the GH:IGF-I ratio plays a central role. Although feed intake reduction has not been reported to last 84 d in sick cattle, the inversion of the GH:IGF-I ratio reported by Henricks et al. (1994)
may occur during the time period when sick cattle are anorexic, and this may contribute to changes in carcass composition of sick cattle.
Ward et al. (1992)
found that fasted cattle have higher serum cortisol concentrations than do fed cattle. Cortisol may be involved in anorexia-associated decreased carcass weight and fatness through decreased thyroid hormone activity (Sharpe, 1987), and increased protein catabolism (Rainia and Jeejeebohoy, 1998).
Brethour (2000)
reported that animals starting a finishing period with little marbling usually fail to grade USDA Choice after feeding periods of less than 200 d. It is possible that feedlot cattle that become sick early in the finishing period have sickness behaviors and anorexia-induced alterations in the deposition of i.m. fat that cause them to have similar constraints on carcass composition during finishing.
Indirect Effects.
The disruption in feed intake experienced by sick cattle may be sufficient in some individuals to cause them to have fewer effective days on feed than their pen mates. Sickness may have an indirect effect on carcass composition because rate and extent of fat deposition changes with days on feed.
Brethour (2000)
used serial ultrasound to generate models of marbling and backfat thickness changes during the finishing period. He found that an exponential model provided the best fit for serial scans of backfat thickness over time, whereas a power function provided the best fit for predicting marbling score. However, a consensus on the actual pattern of fat accretion in feedlot cattle has not been reached. The equation that best fit the Brethour (2000)
serial ultrasound measurements depicted slow deposition of marbling early in the feeding period followed by an increased rate of i.m. fat deposition after cattle reach low Choice. In contrast, Van Koevering et al. (1995)
, using serial slaughter measurements, reported that marbling values reached a plateau and tended not to increase with more days on feed. Using similar techniques, Duckett et al. (1993)
concluded that marbling deposition was nonlinear during finishing, and reported a doubling of i.m. fat content in the longissimus between 84 and 112 d on a high-concentrate diet, and then a plateau in marbling score thereafter. To describe the deposition of external fat over time during the finishing phase using ultrasound measurements, Trenkle (1998)
and Brethour (2000)
reported that carcass backfat increased exponentially with time on feed. Similarly, Camfield et al. (1997)
reported an exponential increase in carcass backfat with time on feed using serial slaughter. In contrast, Van Koevering et al. (1995)
and May et al. (1992)
reported a linear increase in backfat with time on feed using serial slaughter techniques.
If decreased feed intake or other metabolic signals decrease the effective days on feed of sick cattle, then sick cattle should be expected to have less external and i.m. fat compared with their pen mates when the entire pen is slaughtered as a group. External fat deposition seems to proceed in an exponential or linear fashion (Camfield et al., 1997
; Trenkle, 1998
; Brethour, 2000
). As such, decreased effective days on feed should consistently result in decreased backfat thickness of sick animals compared with healthy animals in the same pen. Marbling may be reduced in sick animals compared with healthy pen mates if the pen is slaughtered during or shortly after the time when most of the pen has gone through the period of rapid i.m. fat deposition (Duckett et al., 1993
; Van Koevering et al., 1995
). Alternatively, if the pen is slaughtered well into the period when most of the pen has reached a plateau in marbling score, the sick animals may have enough time to compensate and differences in marbling score between sick and healthy animals may be negligible.
Potential Mechanism for Metabolic Disease Effect on Carcass Characteristics
Very little information is available describing the interactions between acidosis and feedlot performance or carcass traits. One trial using lambs as a model found that a single bout of acidosis depressed rate of fluid passage and rate of absorption of VFA for several months (Krehbiel et al., 1995
). If VFA absorption is disrupted by a single acute bout of acidosis, then growth performance and fat deposition could be affected through the finishing phase of feedlot cattle.
| Implications |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
2 Correspondence: A331 Clydesdale Hall (phone: 573-882-8236; fax: 573-884-9139; e-mail: LarsonR{at}missouri.edu).
Received for publication August 9, 2004. Accepted for publication November 18, 2004.
| Literature Cited |
|---|
|
|
|---|
impairs biologic activity and downstream activation of signals of the insulin-like growth factor I receptor in myoblasts. Endocrinology 144:29882996.
and corticosteroneIndividually and in combination. Am. J. Clin. Nutr 68:12841290.[Abstract]
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |