|
|
||||||||
ANIMAL PRODUCTS |
Roman L. Hruska U.S. Meat Animal Research Center, ARS, USDA, Clay Center, NE 68933-0166
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: Beef Breeds Carcass Palatability Quality Tenderness
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Angus,
Hereford,
Pinzgauer, and
Red Poll) dams were mated by AI to 22 Angus, 21 Hereford (12 polled and nine horned), 21 Red Angus, 22 Charolais, 20 Limousin, 20 Simmental, and 23 Gelbvieh bulls to produce 649 steer calves (Table 1
|
Representative samples of the steers born in 1999 were slaughtered serially in five groups spanning 43 d (May 15, June 11, June 12, June 25, and June 27, 2000). Representative samples of steers born in 2000 were slaughtered serially in four groups spanning 53 d (May 7, May 21, June 11, and June 25, 2001). Final unshrunk live weights were obtained 1 wk before slaughter. The steers were slaughtered in a commercial beef processing facility. After a 36-h chill at 0°C, USDA yield and quality grade data (USDA, 1997
) were obtained by trained MARC personnel.
Samples
Samples for rib dissection and palatability analyses were not obtained from animals slaughtered on June 12, 2000. For all other harvest dates, the wholesale rib (No. 103; NAMP, 1997
) from the right side of each carcass was returned to the meat laboratory at MARC. At 3 d postmortem, the wholesale rib was dissected into the ribeye roll (NAMP No. 112), lean trim, fat trim, and short ribs for prediction of retail product yield as described by Shackelford et al. (1995)
. The ribeye roll was vacuum-packaged and stored at 2°C. Ribeye rolls were frozen at 14 d postmortem at 30°C, and steaks were cut on a band saw. The posterior end of the ribeye roll was squared-off by removing a wedge-shaped slice that was trimmed of all fat, epimysium, and non-LM muscles, and then vacuum-packaged and stored at 30°C for later chemical analysis of the raw LM. Then, four 2.54-cm-thick LM steaks were cut from the posterior end of the ribeye roll. The first steak was not used in this experiment, whereas the second and third steaks were used for trained sensory panel evaluation. The fourth steak was used for determination of Warner-Bratzler shear force and for proximate composition of the cooked LM. Steaks were stored frozen at 30°C for 3 to 5 mo before thawing for evaluation.
Warner-Bratzler Shear Force
Frozen steaks were thawed at 5°C for 24 h and then cooked on a conveyorized belt grill to a final internal temperature of 71°C as described by Wheeler et al. (1998)
. Warner-Bratzler shear force was determined as described by Wheeler et al. (1998)
.
Trained Sensory Evaluation
Immediately after cooking as described previously, the LM was cut into 1 cm x 1 cm x steak thickness cubes. Three cubes were served warm to each panel member. An eight-member descriptive attribute sensory panel, trained according to procedures described by Cross et al. (1978)
, evaluated cooked steaks for tenderness, juiciness, and beef flavor intensity on an eight-point scale (8 = extremely tender, juicy, or intense to 1 = extremely tough, dry, or bland). A warm-up sample was served first, after which four experimental steaks were served in each of two sessions per day (5 min between sessions) and three evaluation days each week. In addition, a duplicate sample to one of the experimental samples was served daily for monitoring panelist and panel performance.
Chemical Composition Analyses
Raw and cooked LM chemical composition (wet weight basis) was determined according to AOAC (1985)
methods as described by Wheeler et al. (2001)
.
Statistical Analyses
Data were analyzed by least squares, mixed-model procedures (Harvey, 1985
) using a model that included a random effect for sires nested within sire breed and fixed effects for sire breed, dam breed, age of dam (4 to 5, 6 to 7, 8 to 9,
10 yr), birth year, interaction of sire breed x dam breed, and covariates for age at weaning (mean = 202 d) and days fed postweaning (mean = 243 d). Sire nested within sire breed was used to test sire breed and residual variance was used to test other fixed effects. Estimates of heritability and genetic and phenotypic correlations were derived following procedures outlined by Harvey (1985)
.
The regression of traits on days fed provides a method of adjusting the age-constant sire breed means to alternative endpoints. The regressions were used for estimating values that would have been obtained if all animals in a sire breed had been fed fewer or more days until the breed group average reached a given endpoint (the mean for this experiment) with regard to age (445 d), carcass weight (363 kg), fat thickness (1.1 cm), fat trim percent (25%; for cuts trimmed to 0 cm of fat cover), or marbling (Small35), following procedures used in previous cycles of GPE (Koch et al., 1979
, 1982b
; Wheeler et al., 1996
, 2001
, 2004
).
Consistent with previous reports (Koch et al., 1979
, 1982b
; Wheeler et al., 1996
, 2001
, 2004
), the average regression over all sire breeds was modified by a proportionate adjustment of the sire breed mean to the general mean as described by Wheeler et al. (1996)
. Sire breeds were compared using the average LSD for
= 0.05 computed for all possible pairwise contrasts using the sire within sire breed mean square as the error term in the linear contrast procedure of Harvey (1985)
.
| Results and Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
At constant age or weight, adjusted fat thickness was higher (P < 0.05) for carcasses from British sire breeds than for Continental European sire breeds (Table 3
). At constant marbling, carcasses from Hereford-sired steers had the highest (P < 0.05) adjusted fat thickness except for Limousin-sired steers. At constant fat trim percent, there were no sire breed differences (P > 0.05) in adjusted fat thickness.
At all endpoints except constant carcass weight, Continental European sire breeds had larger (P < 0.05) LM areas than British sire breeds (Table 3
). At constant weight, LM areas were similar for carcasses from Angus- and Gelbvieh-sired steers. Carcasses from Red Angus-sired steers had smaller (P < 0.05) LM areas than carcasses from Angus-sired steers at all endpoints. Carcasses from Angus-sired steers had larger (P < 0.05) LM areas than those from Hereford-sired steers only at constant age.
At constant age, carcasses from Hereford-sired steers had lower (P < 0.05) percentages of KPH fat than carcasses from all other sire breeds except Charolais and Limousin (Table 3
). At constant age, carcasses from Simmental- and Angus-sired steers had higher (P < 0.05) percentages of KPH fat than all other sire breeds except Red Angus and Gelbvieh. At constant weight, the percentage of KPH fat was lower (P < 0.05) in carcasses from Hereford-sired steers than in carcasses from steers of all sire breeds except Charolais and Limousin. Carcasses from Hereford-sired steers had the lowest (P < 0.05) percentage of KPH fat at constant fat thickness. At constant marbling or fat trim, carcasses from Continental European sire breeds tended to have higher percentages of KPH than carcasses from British sire breeds.
Numerical USDA yield grade was not different (P > 0.05) among sire breeds at constant fat thickness or fat trim endpoints. Yield grade was higher (P < 0.05) for carcasses from British sire breeds at constant age and weight endpoints. At constant marbling, carcasses from Hereford-sired steers had similar (P > 0.05) yield grades as those from Gelbvieh-sired steers, but higher (P < 0.05) yield grades than carcasses from all other sire breeds. Sire breed differences in percentage of carcasses with yield grade of 4.0, or greater, at different endpoints were the same as for yield grade.
At constant age and weight, marbling score was higher (P < 0.05) in carcasses from Red Angus- and Angus-sired steers than for all other sire breeds (Table 3
). At constant fat thickness, carcasses from Red Angus-sired steers had higher (P < 0.05) marbling scores than carcasses from Hereford- or Limousin-sired steers. At constant fat trim, carcasses from Hereford-sired steers tended to have the lowest marbling scores. Sire breed differences for the percentage of carcasses grading USDA Choice at each endpoint were the same as those for marbling differences. Only two carcasses in the experiment graded USDA Standard.
In GPE Cycles I and II, Koch et al. (1976
, 1979)
reported that carcasses from F1 steers of Limousin, Charolais, Simmental, and Gelbvieh sire breeds had larger LM areas, less fat thickness, and lower yield and quality grades compared with carcasses from Hereford x Angus crosses. Gregory et al. (1994b)
found even greater differences in these traits among the carcasses of the same breeds when evaluated as purebred cattle. Results of Wheeler et al. (1996)
indicated that differences in carcass traits between Charolais, Gelbvieh, Hereford, and Angus breeds were similar to those found in previous GPE cycles and to the current evaluation. Kempster et al. (1982)
compared breeds at 16 mo of age after slaughter at a constant fat level, and reported that Hereford steers had heavier carcass weights than Angus steers but lighter than Charolais and Simmental. Others have reported similar differences in carcass traits between Simmental and Hereford, Red Angus, or Angus (Urick et al., 1991
; Mandell et al., 1998
; Laborde et al., 2001
), as did the current evaluation. Differences in carcass traits between Charolais and Angus (Baker and Lunt, 1990
) and between Hereford and Limousin (MacNeil et al., 2001
) similar to the current evaluation have been reported. A serial slaughter at different fat levels resulted in similar findings (Kempster et al., 1988
). Despite the changes in growth rate and size over the last 30 yr, relative differences in carcass traits among Limousin, Charolais, Simmental, Gelbvieh, Hereford, and Angus have not changed significantly.
Carcass Yield
At a constant age of 445 d, carcasses from Continental European sire breeds had the highest (P < 0.05), carcasses from Hereford-sired steers intermediate (P < 0.05), and carcasses from Angus- and Red Angus-sired steers had the lowest (P < 0.05) percentage of retail product yield (Table 4
). At constant weight, carcasses from steers from Continental European sire breeds had the highest (P < 0.05), and carcasses from steers from British sire breeds had the lowest (P < 0.05) percentage of retail product yield. At constant fat thickness and fat trim, sire breed did not affect (P > 0.05) percentage of retail product yield. At constant marbling, carcasses from Hereford-sired steers had lower (P < 0.05) percentages of retail product yield than did carcasses from all sire breeds except Limousin. Differences among sire breeds in fat yield were similar to differences in retail product yield for all endpoints.
|
Carcasses from Continental European sire breeds had heavier weights of retail product for all endpoints than carcasses from British sire breeds. Among Continental European sire breeds, carcasses from Limousin-sired steers had lighter (P < 0.05) weights of retail product than carcasses from Charolais-sired steers at age, fat thickness, and fat trim endpoints. Among British sire breeds, carcasses from Hereford-sired steers had heavier (P < 0.05) weights of retail product than carcasses from Red Angus-sired steers at marbling and fat trim endpoints.
At constant age and weight, carcasses from British sire breeds had heavier (P < 0.05) fat weights than carcasses from Continental European sire breeds (Table 4
). At constant fat thickness, this difference was reversed, so that carcasses from Continental European sire breeds had heavier (P < 0.05) fat weights. At constant marbling, carcasses from Red Angus- and Angus-sired steers had the lighter (P < 0.05) fat weight than carcasses of all other sire breeds. At constant fat trim, carcasses from Hereford-, Angus-, and Red Angus-sired steers had lighter (P < 0.05) fat weights than carcasses from Charolais-, Gelbvieh-, and Simmental-sired steers. Regardless of endpoint, carcasses from Angus-and Red Angus-sired steers tended to have the lightest (P < 0.05) bone weights.
As with other fatness and composition related traits, differences in yield of saleable product have not changed significantly between British and Continental European sire breeds over the last 30 yr. Koch et al., (1976
, 1979)
and Wheeler et al. (1997) have reported that Hereford x Angus crosses have about 4 to 5% lower yield of saleable product than F1 Limousin, Charolais, Simmental, and Gelbvieh carcasses. Others have found similar differences among these sire breeds in carcass yield of saleable product (Mandell et al., 1998
; Laborde et al., 2001
). Kempster et al. (1982)
compared breeds at 16 mo of age after slaughter at a constant fat level, and reported that carcasses from Hereford steers had a lower saleable meat yield than Angus, Charolais, or Simmental steers. Gregory et al. (1994b)
reported differences in the percentage of saleable product of 6 to 10% in purebreds of the same breeds.
Palatability Traits
Differences among sire breeds for LM palatability traits were generally small. At constant age, LM from Gelbvieh-sired steers had higher (P < 0.05) 14-d postmortem Warner-Bratzler shear force values than did the LM from carcasses of steers of all three British sire breeds, and the LM from carcasses of Charolais-sired steers had higher (P < 0.05) 14-d postmortem Warner-Bratzler shear force values than did LM from carcasses of Angus-sired steers (Table 5
). At constant weight, shear force differences were similar to those for constant age, except that LM from Angus-sired steers also had lower (P < 0.05) shear force values than LM from Limousin-sired steers. At constant fat thickness and constant fat trim percent, LM from carcasses of British sire breeds had lower (P < 0.05) shear force than Continental European sire breeds. At constant marbling, 14-d LM Warner-Bratzler shear force values were lower (P < 0.05) for Angus- and Red Angus-sired steers than for the LM from all other sire breeds. The LM from carcasses of steers from Angus dams had slightly lower (P < 0.05) shear force (4.03 kg) compared to LM from carcasses from Hereford or MARC III dams (4.37 and 4.35 kg, respectively).
|
Consistent with the current evaluation, previous comparisons of these sire breeds have indicated small, but generally nonsignificant, differences in LM tenderness between British and Continental European breeds (Koch et al., 1976
, 1979
; Wheeler et al., 1996
). Others have reported similar results (Mandell et al., 1998
; Laborde et al., 2001
). Results from purebred steers have shown that the LM from Angus was tenderer than LM from Limousin, Gelbvieh, Simmental, and Charolais (Gregory et al., 1994b
). Results from previous cycles of GPE (Koch et al., 1976
, 1979
, 1982b
; Wheeler et al., 1996
, 2001
, 2004
) have indicated similar mean LM tenderness among most breeds. Perhaps more important than breed averages is to consider that after 14 d postmortem, the range in breed mean differences was about equal to the range in breeding value within breed, indicating that among breed variation in LM tenderness is approximately the same as variation within breeds (Wheeler et al., 1996
, 2001
, 2004
).
Longissimus Chemical Composition
Chemical composition of raw and cooked LM adjusted to 445 d of age indicated that the LM from carcasses from Angus- and Red Angus-sired steers had higher (P < 0.05) percentages of lipid and lower (P < 0.05) percentages of moisture than the LM from carcasses from all other sire breeds (Table 6
). Differences among sire breeds for percentage of protein in the raw and cooked LM were small in magnitude and seemed to be of little practical importance. Differences among sire breeds in percentage of LM lipid were similar to differences in marbling score and were consistent with previous results (Koch et al., 1976
; Wheeler et al., 2001
).
|
g) and phenotypic (
p) variation. However, phenotypic variation was expressed without doubling R, thereby representing F1 progeny phenotypic variation. Heritability estimates for various carcass, yield, and palatability traits ranged from low (h2 = 0.20 for Warner-Bratzler shear force) to high (h2 = 0.88 for USDA yield grade). Heritability estimates of carcass traits ranged from moderate to high, and were similar to those reported by Wheeler et al. (1996
|
Estimates of the amount of variation between the two extreme breeds for a given trait in standard deviation units (2R/
g) from the present experiment (Table 7
) were lower for most traits when compared with values reported by Wheeler et al. (1996
, 2001
, 2004
). All traits had more variation within breeds than among breeds. These results are consistent with previous data indicating there is as much or more variation in LM tenderness within breeds as among the most extreme breeds for that trait (Wheeler et al., 1996
, 2001
, 2004
). Phenotypic variation in carcass and palatability traits was similar or slightly less than that reported by Wheeler et al. (1996
, 2001
, 2004
). As was observed in Cycles I to VI of GPE, little inherent genetic variation in juiciness and beef flavor intensity was detected in Cycle VII. Phenotypic variation in tenderness rating was approximately twice that of variation in ratings of juiciness and beef flavor intensity (CV = 13.6, 5.7, and 6.1%, respectively). This occurred despite a wide range of marbling scores. Thus, when variation in LM juiciness and beef flavor intensity occurs at the consumer level, it may be mostly induced by cooking practices and the level and kind of flavor enhancers added.
The genetic correlation between fat thickness and marbling was moderately high, suggesting that it would be difficult, but not impossible, to decrease s.c. fat thickness without lowering marbling level (Table 8
). Marbling had relatively high genetic correlations to all carcass traits except weight. The genetic correlation between marbling and palatability traits was higher than reported by Wheeler et al. (2004)
, but similar to those reported by Wheeler et al. (2001)
. Tenderness traits and retail product yield had high genetic correlations to most carcass traits. Shear force and tenderness rating had high genetic correlations to all carcass and palatability traits except for yield traits. Juiciness rating had high genetic correlations to all traits except adjusted fat thickness, yield grade, and retail product yield. Beef flavor intensity rating had moderate to high genetic correlations to all traits.
|
| Implications |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
2 The authors acknowledge the technical assistance of G. Hays, W. Smith, the cattle operations staff, P. Beska, R. Harris, D. Kohmetscher, D. Light, K. Mihm, K. Ostdiek, P. Tammen, J. Waechter, and the secretarial assistance of M. Bierman. ![]()
3 Correspondence: P.O. Box 166 (phone: 402-762-4229; fax: 402-762-4149; e-mail: wheeler{at}email.marc.usda.gov).
Received for publication May 4, 2004. Accepted for publication October 15, 2004.
| Literature Cited |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
E. Casas, S. N. White, S. D. Shackelford, T. L. Wheeler, M. Koohmaraie, G. L. Bennett, and T. P. L. Smith Assessing the association of single nucleotide polymorphisms at the thyroglobulin gene with carcass traits in beef cattle J Anim Sci, November 1, 2007; 85(11): 2807 - 2814. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. A. Cushman, M. F. Allan, R. M. Thallman, and L. V. Cundiff Characterization of biological types of cattle (Cycle VII): Influence of postpartum interval and estrous cycle length on fertility J Anim Sci, September 1, 2007; 85(9): 2156 - 2162. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. L. Gruber, J. D. Tatum, T. E. Engle, M. A. Mitchell, S. B. Laudert, A. L. Schroeder, and W. J. Platter Effects of ractopamine supplementation on growth performance and carcass characteristics of feedlot steers differing in biological type J Anim Sci, July 1, 2007; 85(7): 1809 - 1815. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. N. White, E. Casas, M. F. Allan, J. W. Keele, W. M. Snelling, T. L. Wheeler, S. D. Shackelford, M. Koohmaraie, and T. P. L. Smith Evaluation in beef cattle of six deoxyribonucleic acid markers developed for dairy traits reveals an osteopontin polymorphism associated with postweaning growth J Anim Sci, January 1, 2007; 85(1): 1 - 10. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
E. Casas, S. N. White, T. L. Wheeler, S. D. Shackelford, M. Koohmaraie, D. G. Riley, C. C. Chase Jr., D. D. Johnson, and T. P. L. Smith Effects of calpastatin and {micro}-calpain markers in beef cattle on tenderness traits J Anim Sci, March 1, 2006; 84(3): 520 - 525. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. Bergen, S. P. Miller, J. W. Wilton, D. H. Crews Jr., and I. B. Mandell Genetic correlations between live yearling bull and steer carcass traits adjusted to different slaughter end points. 1. Carcass lean percentage J Anim Sci, March 1, 2006; 84(3): 546 - 557. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. T. Stone, E. Casas, T. P. L. Smith, J. W. Keele, G. Harhay, G. L. Bennett, M. Koohmaraie, T. L. Wheeler, S. D. Shackelford, and W. M. Snelling Identification of genetic markers for fat deposition and meat tenderness on bovine chromosome 5: Development of a low-density single nucleotide polymorphism map J Anim Sci, October 1, 2005; 83(10): 2280 - 2288. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. N. White, E. Casas, T. L. Wheeler, S. D. Shackelford, M. Koohmaraie, D. G. Riley, C. C. Chase Jr., D. D. Johnson, J. W. Keele, and T. P. L. Smith A new single nucleotide polymorphism in CAPN1 extends the current tenderness marker test to include cattle of Bos indicus, Bos taurus, and crossbred descent J Anim Sci, September 1, 2005; 83(9): 2001 - 2008. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |