Journal of Animal Science, Vol 77, Issue 7 1735-1741, Copyright © 1999 by American Society of Animal Science

JOURNAL ARTICLE

An audit of retail beef loin steak tenderness conducted in eight U.S. cities

M. H. George, J. D. Tatum, K. E. Belk and G. C. Smith
Department of Animal Sciences, Colorado State University, Fort Collins 80523, USA.

An audit of supermarkets in eight U.S. cities was conducted to characterize retail beef loin steaks with respect to grade, postfabrication aging, and tenderness and to provide an interim measure of progress in industry efforts to improve retail beef tenderness. Top sirloin steaks (n = 819) and strip loin steaks (n = 827 paired steaks) were purchased at retail markets in Atlanta, Chicago, Denver, Houston, Philadelphia, Phoenix, San Francisco, and Seattle and shipped to Colorado State University for measurement of shear force (both cut types) and evaluation by a trained sensory panel (strip loins only). Approximately 80% of the steaks originated from beef plants in Kansas, Texas, Nebraska, and Colorado. Postfabrication aging periods ranged from 2 to 87 d (mean = 20.8 d) for top sirloin steaks and from 2 to 91 d (mean = 19.2 d) for strip loin steaks, although most top sirloin (85%) and strip loin (91%) steaks were available for purchase 7 to 35 d after fabrication. The mix of quality grades was similar for both cuts: 60% Select, 31% "commodity" Choice, 6 to 7% "Certified" Choice, and 2 to 3% Prime. Shear force averaged 3.46 kg (SD = .74) for top sirloins and 3.05 kg (SD = .95) for strip loins; 75% of both steak types had shear force values between 2 and 4 kg. Postfabrication periods shorter than 7 d were associated with reduced (P < .05) tenderness, especially for top sirloin steaks. Higher quality grades were associated with greater (P < .05) tenderness (Prime > Choice > Select) for both cuts. Based on panel tenderness ratings, the approximate odds of obtaining a "slightly tough" or tougher strip loin steak at a retail supermarket were: 0 for Prime, 1 in 10 for "Certified" Choice, 1 in 5 for "commodity" Choice, and 1 in 4 for Select. Audit results suggest that tenderness characteristics of loin steaks have not changed materially since the National Beef Tenderness Survey was conducted in 1991 and that two primary focal points of the beef industry's efforts to improve tenderness should be 1) to prevent short-aged (< 7 d postfabrication) product from reaching consumers and 2) to identify methods for enhancing tenderness of Select and "commodity" Choice beef.

This article has been cited by other articles:

				P. S. Brewer, J. M. James, C. R. Calkins, R. M. Rasby, T. J. Klopfenstein, and R. V. Anderson Carcass traits and M. longissimus lumborum palatability attributes of calf- and yearling-finished steers J Anim Sci, May 1, 2007; 85(5): 1239 - 1246. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				K. M. Killinger, C. R. Calkins, W. J. Umberger, D. M. Feuz, and K. M. Eskridge Consumer sensory acceptance and value for beef steaks of similar tenderness, but differing in marbling level J Anim Sci, November 1, 2004; 82(11): 3294 - 3301. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				W. J. Platter, J. D. Tatum, K. E. Belk, P. L. Chapman, J. A. Scanga, and G. C. Smith Relationships of consumer sensory ratings, marbling score, and shear force value to consumer acceptance of beef strip loin steaks J Anim Sci, November 1, 2003; 81(11): 2741 - 2750. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]