Journal of Animal Science, Vol 77, Issue 3 558-568, Copyright © 1999 by American Society of Animal Science

JOURNAL ARTICLE

"Quasi-REML" correlation estimates between production and health traits in the presence of selection and confounding: a simulation study

P. Gates, K. Johansson and B. Danell
Department of Animal Breeding and Genetics, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Uppsala.

Performance of the "quasi-REML" method for estimating correlations between a continuous trait and a categorical trait, and between two categorical traits, was studied with Monte Carlo simulations. Three continuous, correlated traits were simulated for identical populations and three scenarios with either no selection, selection for one moderately heritable trait (Trait 1, h2 = .25), and selection for the same trait plus confounding between sires and management groups. The "true" environmental correlations between Traits 2 (h2 = .10) and 3 (h2 = .05) were always of the same absolute size (.20), but further data scenarios were generated by setting the sign of environmental correlation to either positive or negative. Observations for Traits 2 and 3 were then reassigned to binomial categories to simulate health or reproductive traits with incidences of 15 and 5%, respectively. Genetic correlations (r(g12), r(g13), and r(g23) and environmental correlations (r(e12), r(e13), and r(e23)) were estimated for the underlying continuous scale (REML) and the visible categorical scales ("quasi-REML") with linear multiple-trait sire and animal models. Contrary to theory, practically all "quasi-REML" genetic correlations were underestimated to some extent with the sire and animal models. Selection inflated this negative bias for sire model estimates, and the sign of r(e23) noticeably affected r(g23) estimates for the animal model, with greater bias and SD for estimates when the "true" r(e23) was positive. Transformed "quasi-REML" environmental correlations between a continuous and a categorical trait were estimated with good efficiency and little bias, and corresponding correlations between two categorical traits were systematically overestimated. Confounding between sires and contemporary groups negatively affected all correlation estimates on the underlying and the visible scales, especially for sire model "quasi-REML" estimates of genetic correlation. Selection, data structure, and the (co)variance structure influences how well correlations involving categorical traits are estimated with "quasi-REML" methods.

This article has been cited by other articles:

				I. M. Andersen-Ranberg, B. Heringstad, D. Gianola, Y. M. Chang, and G. Klemetsdal Comparison Between Bivariate Models for 56-Day Nonreturn and Interval from Calving to First Insemination in Norwegian Red J Dairy Sci, June 1, 2005; 88(6): 2190 - 2198. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				B. Heringstad, Y. M. Chang, D. Gianola, and G. Klemetsdal Genetic Association Between Susceptibility to Clinical Mastitis and Protein Yield in Norwegian Dairy Cattle J Dairy Sci, April 1, 2005; 88(4): 1509 - 1514. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				W. F. Fikse Comparison of Performance Records and National Breeding Values as Input into International Genetic Evaluation J Dairy Sci, August 1, 2004; 87(8): 2709 - 2719. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				M. Hansen, P. Madsen, J. Jensen, J. Pedersen, and L. G. Christensen Genetic Parameters of Postnatal Mortality in Danish Holstein Calves J Dairy Sci, May 1, 2003; 86(5): 1807 - 1817. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]